Thursday, August 4, 2016

There are Dangers of Abusive Scholarship About The BIble


1 Peter 2:9

9But you are a chosen race, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, God’s own people, in order that you may proclaim the mighty acts of him who called you out of darkness into his marvelous light.

Peter takes us to a throwback to the first chapter of the gospel of John.  Actually, it may not be a throwback.  One of the great arguments of the New Testament scholarship community is when all the books were written.  They were not arranged in chronological order in the New Testament.  Paul’s letters are probably the earliest pieces written down, followed by the rest. 

In this regard, it is possible that Peter published this activity of Jesus, that He called us out of darkness and into his marvelous light, ahead of the publishing of the gospel of John, where this comes in the first chapter.  Such arguments are the stuff of doctrinal theses and scholarly debates, and they carry with them the risk of putting us to sleep.  

The downside of those arguments, of which was written first, is when a value judgement is attached to the chronology, i.e. the earlier is better or more “original” to Jesus.  That implies that Jesus’ words and deeds were somehow padded by the later authors, maybe ‘edited’ more to make a point, maybe not as ‘original’ as the stuff Jesus really did.  Scholars don’t come out and say that too often, but the implication is there.

The trouble is, there is no way, two thousand years later, to really know for sure.  And the trouble is engaging in this argument in the first place.  What I mean is that the WHOLE bible is useful for teaching, for uplifting, for preparing us for what God wants.  The fact is that Jesus called us out of darkness into His marvelous light.  Don’t dim the light with semantic arguments that chip away at the great truths of thousands of years of our faith.
Besides, we accept Jesus on faith, not "academic certainty".

No comments:

Post a Comment